Why Can’t I Eat Glistering Melon

14/09/2022 admin 60 Views

Search
- Search all Forums
- Search this Forum
- Search this Thread
Tools
- Bound to Forum

Glistering melon should provide assistance

#1

May 17, 2013

I noticed that Glistering melons are not eatable. I feel they should, but they should give yous atleast 1/2 a centre and give you the aforementioned nutrient bar refil every bit regular melons do. Anyone agree?

Rollback Post to Revision

RollBack

#two

May 17, 2013

I do, I found it odd how they made the golden carrot edible simply not the glistering melon. Also fermented spider eyes.

Rollback Post to Revision

RollBack

Praise be to Spode.
#3

May 17, 2013

I noticed that Glistering melons are not eatable. I feel they should, merely they should requite you atleast 1/two a centre and give you the same food bar refil every bit regular melons do. Anyone agree?

Only they’re coated with aureate, somehow I don’t think they would be very healthy….

Why not, I guess. I just don’t retrieve of information technology as much of an event, as eating them would be wasting a gold nugget anyway. I don’t concord that they should provide instant wellness, nonetheless, as that would remove the whole intent of the hunger organization.

Rollback Mail to Revision

RollBack
#4

May 17, 2013

But they’re coated with golden, somehow I don’t remember they would be very healthy….

Why not, I approximate. I just don’t call back of information technology as much of an result, as eating them would be wasting a gilt nugget anyway. I don’t concur that they should provide instant health, nevertheless, as that would remove the whole intent of the hunger system.

Peradventure mayhap then they could replenish more than hunger like possibly similar 4 rather than the regular melon being two?

Rollback Post to Revision

RollBack
#5

May 17, 2013

That ruins the signal of making a healing potion, considering players volition only spam eat these glistering melons instead of making the potion. Kinda making the potion be in the game for zippo. And I don’t think health healing food will e’er come up back.

Rollback Post to Revision

RollBack

Hey, yous at that place. Yes, you lot! Are y’all thinking about posting a proffer on the forums anytime soon? If so, delight read
this
before doing and then.
#half-dozen

May 17, 2013

Mayhap maybe then they could replenish more hunger like maybe like 4 rather than the regular melon being ii?

I don’t hateful to push the envelope, just why? They’re intended, I believe, equally a potion ingredient alone, non food. You should only want to swallow it in an emergency; if you brand a glistering melon, just don’t use it in brewing (every bit in you swallow it), information technology should be largely wasted. Otherwise, crafting glistering melons would exist something to do to
all
of your melon slices, not just the ones y’all demand, and I don’t recollect that’south a proficient thing.

Rollback Mail service to Revision

RollBack
#7

May 17, 2013

That ruins the point of making a healing potion, because players will just spam eat these glistering melons instead of making the potion. Kinda making the potion be in the game for nothing. And I don’t retrieve health healing nutrient volition ever come back.

Well, considering information technology is only half a heart, and eating nutrient takes near the aforementioned fourth dimension equally potions, I would rather use the potion.

Rollback Mail service to Revision

RollBack
#8

May 17, 2013

Well, because it is only one-half a heart, and eating food takes about the same time as potions, I would rather utilize the potion.

That won’t end people from eating the healing melon because they’re likewise lazy to make the potion. And I doubt Mojang would reimplement healing food when they deliberately removed it.

Concluding edited by
0_Zippy:
May 17, 2013

Rollback Post to Revision

RollBack

Hey, yous there. Yes, you! Are you thinking about posting a proffer on the forums anytime shortly? If so, please read
this
before doing and so.
#nine

May twenty, 2013

Rollback Mail service to Revision

RollBack
#10

May 20, 2013

Rollback Post to Revision

RollBack

Top 5 priority of minecraft:

1- Cease the mod API

2- Give brains to villagers (make em more usefull)

three- Add ambiance: birds, fishes, bugs, crabs on beaches, monkeys in jungles…

4- More than plants! Aquatic, any fruit tree, bushes….

5- Ambiant sounds!
____________________________________________

My supports

“Don’t waste Fire. Retrieve of all the starving children, and how good they would taste on fire.”
#11

May 20, 2013

I don’t hateful to push the envelope, simply why? They’re intended, I believe, equally a potion ingredient alone, not food. You should merely want to eat it in an emergency; if you make a glistering melon, but don’t use it in brewing (as in you eat it), it should be largely wasted. Otherwise, crafting glistering melons would be something to do to
all
of your melon slices, not only the ones you demand, and I don’t think that’south a skillful thing.

A layer of gilded leaf painted onto or flaked into various high-quality foods (especially desserts) is not uncommon. Gold is edible in modest enough amounts, though large amounts result in heavy metallic poisoning… Possible side effect for eating as well much in a certain time-menstruum?

I’ve always thought that Glistering Melon and Golden Carrots should be edible, and I recall that since they’re a brewing component they ought each to have special effects. Minor compared to what their last potions accomplish, but a little taste of their unrefined power, eh?

Rollback Post to Revision

RollBack
#12

May 20, 2013

Support.

People spamming these because of laziness are choosing to do that, and then what? They could make a potion, or they could just swallow the melons.

Rollback Post to Revision

RollBack
#xiv

May 20, 2013

Hello there CodenameDuchess, I would like to innovate you my friends, Gilded Apple and Aureate Carrot. We’ re friends since childhood, and they are completely edible.

I’g pretty certain you tin’t eat the golden carrot. It used to exist that way maybe? But currently they’re inedible… aren’t they?

Rollback Post to Revision

RollBack
#15

May 20, 2013

I’1000 pretty sure you can’t consume the golden carrot. It used to be that fashion maybe? But currently they’re inedible… aren’t they?

Nope. Edible.

As for the idea information technology is such a depression amount of wellness that I don’t see a need to add it. One trip to the Nether and you tin be getting way more than health per melon.

Rollback Mail service to Revision

RollBack
#16

May 20, 2013

Nope. Edible.

Equally for the idea it is such a low corporeality of health that I don’t come across a demand to add it. One trip to the Nether and you tin can exist getting way more health per melon.

Whaaaaat? Maybe I got mixed up. They used to not be edible, right?

Either way, my bad Coga19000 – I was totes wrong.

Rollback Postal service to Revision

RollBack
#17

May 20, 2013

but make them editable. idk what features they have. its basically like a plot hole. they SHOULD be editable, and they are non..

Carrot = Editable

gilt + Carrot = Editable

Melon = Editable

Melon + gilt = Not editable.(????)

Final edited past
lceEye:
May xx, 2013

Rollback Post to Revision

RollBack
#18

May 20, 2013

I don’t mean to push button the envelope, only why? They’re intended, I believe, as a potion ingredient alone, non nutrient. You should just want to eat information technology in an emergency; if you make a glistering melon, merely don’t use information technology in brewing (every bit in y’all eat it), it should be largely wasted. Otherwise, crafting glistering melons would be something to practice to
all
of your melon slices, not just the ones yous need, and I don’t call up that’s a practiced thing.

so are golden carrots, and they heal more hunger the normal carrots. so everything you but says makes near no sense in relation to things that are already in minecraft.

Rollback Postal service to Revision

RollBack
#xix

May xx, 2013

Support! Golden apples an carrots are edible but melons are not!

Rollback Post to Revision

RollBack
#20

May twenty, 2013

Y’all got me, and you take my sincere apologies. Cheers for informing me about the gilt food, although I call up I knew of them somewhere in the back of my mind. I do desire to defend myself besides, though. Golden apples don’t fill up your hunger meter any more than regular apples, so why should melons? In this case, I don’t think either of us tin be right nor wrong, although it is entirely possible I am forgetting something once more.

I also want to say that I was never against consumable glistering melons, but against making them give yous twice every bit much hunger, and having consuming them exist a practical idea. I would, somewhat happily, yield 1.5 times the hunger, and that even makes more than sense when using the aureate carrot model.

Realizing my mistakes, I shall now make an try to withdraw from this thread. However, I volition allow myself the following question, as I do non remember it can exactly be chosen “negative”, and can be used in favor of the idea as much as it can be against it. Why not just eat the melon and allow the hunger-regeneration arrangement have over?

That’southward all, and I repent over again.

Rollback Mail service to Revision

RollBack
#21

May 20, 2013

np, i don’t call up it should heal health either. simply be ediable

Rollback Post to Revision

RollBack
To mail service a comment, please login.

Source: https://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-java-edition/suggestions/80771-glistering-melon-should-provide-aid